作者: 吳博貴 醫師 / 醫學博士
(前言的前言)此篇文章的開頭,先聲明一點。我認為『推拿』是中華民族的一個相當博大精深的傳統醫學。對於許多的疾病,均有相當的幫助!但就如西藥一樣,再好再貴的藥,若用在錯誤的時機上,均會造成莫大的副作用!
 
(前言)在2006年的某一天,那時我還是住院醫師第二年。我的恩師 陳威明教授突然問了我『博貴啊,你有沒有觀察到有些骨肉瘤的病人,好像都有去給人推拿過,而且好像結果都比較不好。你去研究一下吧』。因此,我們就一方面遇到新的骨肉瘤病患時,都會先耳提面命一番;另一方面,開始進行大規模的調查統計。終於,在一年過後有了初步的結論。於是在2007年秋天,我們在中華民國骨科醫學會與全世界的國際肢體保留協會(International Society of Limb Salvage, ISOLS)發表我們的研究。並在2010年,在著名的骨科雜誌 Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, British發表(現已改名為The Bone & Joint Journal)。(註一) 


(本文)根據我們的研究,在台灣診斷出骨肉瘤(Osteosarcoma)前,有52%的病人曾經因為誤以為肌肉酸痛或生長痛,而在國術館或中醫接受過推拿(manipulation)。而這些骨肉瘤病患,相對於沒有接受過推拿的骨肉瘤病患,其預後較差(poor prognosis)、肺部轉移機會較高(higher lung metastasis rate)而且手術後腫瘤局部再復發(higher local recurrence rate)的機會也較高。


2010年,刊登在著名骨科雜誌 Journal of Bone and Joint Surgery, British

 

平均手術前推拿的次數

 

 

平均手術前推拿的週數

 

We evaluated the long-term outcome of patients with an osteosarcoma who had undergone prior manipulative therapy, a popular treatment in Asia, and investigated its effects on several prognostic factors. Of the 134 patients in this study, 70 (52%) patients had manipulative therapy and 64 (48%) did not. The age, location, and size of tumour were not significantly different between the groups. The five-year overall survival rate was 58% and 92% in the groups with and without manipulative therapy (p = 0.004). Both the primary and overall rates of lung metastasis were significantly higher in the manipulative group (primary: 32% vs 3%, p = 0.003; overall lung metastasis rate: 51.4% vs 18.8%, p < 0.001). Patients who had manipulative therapy had higher local recurrence rates in comparison to patients who did not (29% vs 6%, p = 0.011). The prognosis for patients with osteosarcoma who had manipulative therapy was significantly poorer than those who had not. Manipulative therapy was an independent factor for survival. This form of therapy may serve as a mechanism to accelerate the spread of tumour cells, and therefore must be avoided in order to improve the outcome for patients with an osteosarcoma.
 



此外,因臨床回朔性之研究(retrospective study)常會有偏差(bias),因此我們也做了基礎實驗與動物實驗。我們將MG-63的骨肉瘤細胞株植入老鼠體中,並給實驗鼠進行推拿。發現14天過後,這些老鼠的肺部均發現MG-63的骨肉瘤細胞,此外,代表著合併轉移的指標『MMP-9』,也較沒有經過推拿的實驗鼠增高許多。這個結論,我們發表在2011年的國際肢體保留協會與2014年《公共科學圖書館期刊》(PLoS One) 之中。 (註二)

2014年,刊登在著名骨科雜誌 PLOS one



因此,不論是在我們在臨床上的觀察,與實驗室的動物研究,都證明手術前在病灶處推拿會造成相當的影響。因此,我們再這裡強烈建議與拜託各位,若有聽說附近周遭的人疑似或確定罹患骨肉瘤或其他骨腫瘤,請提醒他(她)切勿在患部行推拿、熱敷、針灸或拔罐等行為,以免腫瘤受到機械另外力而到處擴散。

 

註一: 
The prognosis for patients with osteosarcoma who have received prior manipulative therapy. Bone Joint J. 2010;92-B(11):1580-1585. 
註二: 
Manipulation therapy prior to diagnosis induced primary osteosarcoma metastasis--from clinical to basic research. Tang C-H, ed. PLoS ONE. 2014;9(5).